EU Startups: news and funding

EU Auditors: Half of Horizon 2020's €17bn for Industry Went to Non-Profits, and SMEs Got 14% of InnovFin Money

TL;DR: what did the EU auditors find about Horizon 2020 funding for companies?

On 15 October 2026, the European Court of Auditors published Special Report 24/2026 on the €17 billion "industrial leadership" part of Horizon 2020, the 2014–2020 money meant to help companies, especially SMEs, bring research to market. Only around half of the support went to close-to-market actions, and around half of the funding went to non-profit organisations. SMEs were 47% of InnovFin recipients but got 14% of the money. Of 13 SME Instrument companies the auditors visited, 7 reached commercialisation but saw no market uptake. The report is meant to shape the next Horizon Europe (2028–2034), and the Commission rejected one of its four recommendations outright.
Audit reports rarely change a grant call overnight. This one matters because it lands while the EU is writing the rules for its next research and competitiveness programmes, and because it describes, project by project, how SMEs actually used EU innovation money. Here's what the auditors found, what the Commission answered, and what it means for your next application.

What happened

The European Court of Auditors (ECA) checks how the EU spends its money. Its new special report looks at Horizon 2020's "industrial leadership" priority, which had a budget of around €17 billion out of about €79 billion for the whole programme. About 80% of it went to six technology areas (ICT, nanotechnologies, advanced materials, biotechnology, advanced manufacturing and processing, and space). The rest paid for access to risk finance and for innovation in SMEs.
The auditors reviewed 33 completed projects (18 collaborative and 15 single-company projects), visited 25 SMEs in Finland, Hungary, Italy, the Netherlands and Spain, and surveyed 172 SMEs. The report was adopted on 16 September 2026 and published on 15 October. The ECA's press release sums it up in one line: "EU support struggles to fill the gap between research and commercialisation".
Petri Sarvamaa, the ECA Member in charge of the audit, said: "There is a persistent gap between research and commercialisation, even for close-to-market research. The next generation of EU research and competitiveness programmes must ensure this gap is significantly reduced". One small step in that direction is open now: the Horizon Europe 'Proof of market' call offers around 24 grants of about €200,000 to small consortia of spin-offs, startups and SMEs that take earlier Cluster 4 or Horizon 2020 results to market, with a deadline of 2 February 2027.

The main findings, instrument by instrument

InstrumentBudgetWhat the auditors found
LEIT collaborative projects (ICT, NMBP, space)~€13.6bnAbout 54% of LEIT funding went to research and coordination actions, which address earlier stages. Half of LEIT and SME innovation support went to about 550 entities (3.8% of participants), mainly non-profits. Most sampled projects centred on TRL 6.
InnovFin (loans, guarantees, equity via the EIB Group)~€2.8bnMinimum loan thresholds, often €25 million, kept out smaller firms. SMEs were 47% of final recipients but got 14% of financing (€1.42bn of €10.5bn). No data on whether EIF products helped SME innovation.
SME Instrument (single-company grants)~€0.6bnEffective for technology transfer: 10 of 13 SMEs visited went from concept to validated innovation. Weak market uptake: 7 of 13 commercialised without market uptake, 2 had zero growth.
Source: European Court of Auditors, Special Report 24/2026 (paragraphs 26–29, 33, 47–52 and Annex I). Budget figures are approximate, as given in the report.

Why SMEs got less than the rules promised

Horizon 2020 was supposed to help companies, particularly SMEs, turn ideas into products. The report lists several reasons why that only partly happened:
  • Non-profits got most of the money and the best rates. For-profit entities, including SMEs, were 76% of the roughly 14,500 participants, but around half of the funding went to research organisations and universities. The 10 research organisations that received the most took part in more than 1,700 of 6,115 projects (28%). Non-profits often got a 100% funding rate in innovation actions, against 70% for companies, which the auditors say "lacked any incentive effect" to bring in private money.
  • SMEs rarely led. Collaborative projects took nearly 80% of Horizon 2020 funding, and SMEs were mostly non-leading partners. That limited their say over project direction, intellectual property and commercial exploitation. Evidence from early Horizon Europe suggests the pattern continues.
  • Some joined to network. 5 of the 13 SMEs in collaborative projects named networking with key industry players as one of their main reasons to take part. One Hungarian SME took part in at least 12 projects only as a service provider, writing proposals and doing market analysis for its partners.
  • The impact criterion was applied unevenly. Of 30 evaluation summary reports reviewed, only 3 assessed expected economic impact and scale-up potential. In 15, scores were based on turnover and staff numbers without explanation; in 12, an overall impact score had no justification. The auditors' verdict: the "scores may appear arbitrary and their reliability doubtful".
  • No eligibility test for innovation capacity. Neither Horizon 2020 nor Horizon Europe asks applicants to show innovation capacity, so money may not reach the participants with the strongest innovation potential.
If you write proposals, the impact finding is the one to remember. See how evaluators score each criterion in our guide to grant application scoring, and how to write measurable results in expected outcomes and impact measurement.

After the grant: the follow-on money gap

Most SME Instrument companies the auditors visited did the technical work. The problem came afterwards. 7 of the 13 single-company SMEs reached the commercialisation stage but didn't achieve market uptake, held back by financial constraints, market obstacles, staffing, regulation and technology barriers. 7 of 13 also said they needed more support after the project ended, and two SMEs stopped operating or dropped their R&I activities. Among the 12 visited SMEs in collaborative projects, 7 didn't commercialise their output at all.
The report also says the grant and equity sides of EU funding didn't talk to each other: the EIC and the EIC Fund "were not systematically linked" to grant-funded projects. And the Commission never checked, at project closure, which results had commercial potential, so it had no basis for deciding who deserved follow-up funding.
The auditors also compared business plans with real accounts. At least 3 of the 13 single-company SMEs had overestimated their growth by at least a third. One Italian SME's revenue was about 15% of its plan in 2021 and 1% in 2024. A Spanish SME with €1.5 million in assets in 2015 planned €80 million by 2019 and reached €4 million.
Two more data problems: only 147 of 642 patent applications reported for LEIT projects (about 23%) were filed after the projects started, so the patent indicator was "systematically" overreported. And the Commission's project database doesn't record trade secrets or software licences, which 7 of the 25 SMEs visited relied on instead of patents.

What the auditors recommend, and what the Commission said

The report makes four recommendations, mainly for the 2028–2034 Horizon Europe programme and the proposed European Competitiveness Fund (ECF). The Commission's official replies say that, because those programmes are still being negotiated, it can by default only partially accept or reject recommendations about them. It also refuses recommendations 1 and 2 as regards the ECF, saying Horizon Europe and the ECF will be "two self-standing programmes".
RecommendationTarget dateCommission's answer
1. Shift support to higher TRLs, apply the impact criterion consistently, set targets for for-profit and SME participation (also in EIB agreements), expand market-uptake and dissemination supportQ1 2028Partially accepted, for Horizon Europe only
2. Identify projects with commercial potential after they end, and fund the market entry and scale-up of the companies behind them2027Partially accepted, for Horizon Europe only
3. Restructure monitoring for 2028–2034 to track innovation capacity and companies' economic performance2027Not accepted
4. Evaluate Horizon Europe's impact on participants' economic performance and innovation capacity2031Partially accepted
Sources: European Court of Auditors, Special Report 24/2026; replies of the European Commission. On recommendation 3, the Commission says its proposals for the next budget were adopted in July 2025 and that all indicators will now sit in a separate Performance Regulation.
The Commission's replies also restate what it's doing for startups now. The EIC Accelerator combines a grant of up to €2.5 million with equity of up to €10 million (up to €30 million under STEP Scale Up). The Scaleup Europe Fund is designed as a third compartment of the EIC Fund with a target size of €5 billion, anchored by €1 billion from the EIC's Horizon Europe budget in 2026 and 2027. Its proposal for 2028–2034 would triple EIC support. Status: Proposed, not adopted.

Why it matters now

The EU is negotiating its next long-term budget. The Commission proposes about €409 billion for the ECF and Horizon Europe together (€362 billion in 2025 prices), around 21% of a proposed €1,984 billion budget for 2028–2034. Status: Proposed. Member states have already pushed back: in the Council's negotiating box, EU governments want to cut the next Horizon Europe by €16.8 billion. Parliament's research committee is due to vote on its position on the next Horizon Europe on 10 November, Science|Business reported. Status: Debated.
This is the second ECA report this month that SMEs should read. The Court's 2025 annual report found that SMEs made up 9% of the research sample but 30% of the errors. Together, the two reports point the same way: closer checks on what companies claim, both in costs and in results.

What this means for you

  1. Take a leading role, or at least own the results. The auditors tie weak commercialisation to SMEs being junior partners. If you can't coordinate, negotiate a clear work package, IP ownership and exploitation rights in the consortium agreement. Our guide to consortium requirements explains the roles.
  2. Make your impact section easy to score. Evaluators were criticised for unexplained impact scores, so expect more scrutiny of market size, buyers, pricing and the path to revenue. Back every claim with numbers.
  3. Keep the business plan realistic. The audit compared plans with real financial statements, and since 2023 the Commission has pulled company financial data on participants from the external Orbis database. Overstated forecasts can come back to you in a later application.
  4. Plan the money for after the grant. Funding constraints were the main barrier to market uptake. Line up the next step before the project ends: the EIC Accelerator, investors or a national agency.
  5. Don't count on EIB loans if you're small. InnovFin's €25 million minimum tickets shut most SMEs out. Look at bank loans backed by EU guarantees and at equity instead; our map of EU and national loans, guarantees and equity lists the options.
Never miss a deadline

All open EU and national calls are in our grant deadlines calendar.

FAQ: the EU auditors' report on Horizon 2020 and SMEs

What is ECA Special Report 24/2026?

It's the European Court of Auditors' report on Horizon 2020's "industrial leadership" priority, titled "EU funding for innovation and competitiveness – Limited focus on close-to-market measures under Horizon 2020's 'industrial leadership' priority". It was published on 15 October 2026.

How much money did the audit cover?

Around €17 billion for 2014–2020: about €13.6 billion for leadership in enabling and industrial technologies, €2.8 billion for access to risk finance (InnovFin) and about €0.6 billion for the SME Instrument.

Did SMEs get a fair share of InnovFin?

According to the EIB data quoted in the report, SMEs were 47% of InnovFin's final recipients but received 14% of its financing, €1.42 billion out of €10.5 billion. Minimum loan thresholds of often €25 million kept many smaller firms out.

Did the SME Instrument work?

Partly. 10 of the 13 single-company SMEs the auditors visited went from concept to validated innovation, but 7 of the 13 reached commercialisation without market uptake, and 2 had zero growth.

Did the Commission accept the recommendations?

It partially accepted recommendations 1, 2 and 4 (for Horizon Europe only) and rejected recommendation 3 on restructuring monitoring for 2028–2034. It also rejected recommendations 1 and 2 as regards the European Competitiveness Fund.

Does this change Horizon Europe calls today?

Not directly. The recommendations target the 2028–2034 programmes, with dates from 2027 to 2031. But the findings on impact scoring and business plans are a good guide for how proposals and results will be checked from now on.
2026-10-24 08:21 Funding news