EU Startups: news and funding

EU Auditors Check the 12 Research Partnerships: Staff-Cost Errors Persist, and the Chips JU Used Only 42% of Its 2025 Payment Budget

TL;DR: what did the EU auditors find in the EU's research partnerships?

On 23 October 2026, the European Court of Auditors published its annual audit of the 12 EU joint undertakings, the public-private partnerships that run EU research money for chips, hydrogen, aviation, health, supercomputing, rail, 6G, cybersecurity and fusion. Their accounts are reliable and their spending is regular overall, but errors in grant payments persist, mainly in staff costs, with no real improvement from Horizon 2020 to Horizon Europe. The auditors qualified their opinion on the payments of Global Health EDCTP3, where 4 of 5 sampled grant payments were affected. The partnerships used 73% of their 2025 payment budgets on average: the Chips JU used 42% because its grant agreements were late, and the SNS JU used 18%.
Joint undertakings don't get many headlines, but they run some of the biggest EU calls a deep-tech startup or SME can join. The new audit tells you two useful things before you apply: where cost claims go wrong, and which partnerships were slow to sign grants and pay. Here's what the auditors found and what it means for you.

What happened

The European Court of Auditors (ECA) checks the accounts and payments of the EU's joint undertakings (JUs) every year. Its annual report for the 2025 financial year covers 12 of them, based in Belgium, Luxembourg, Spain and Romania. Ten are research and innovation partnerships, such as Chips, Clean Hydrogen, Clean Aviation and EuroHPC, and one is the European Cybersecurity Competence Centre (ECCC); these 11 are co-funded by the EU and their other members, mainly industry. The twelfth, Fusion for Energy (F4E), manages Europe's contribution to the ITER fusion project.
The ECA's press release gives the overall verdict: the partnerships "kept their finances in good order overall in 2025". All 12 got a clean opinion on their accounts, and revenue and payments were legal and regular overall. The estimated overall level of error was below the ECA's 2% materiality threshold. This is the first year the ECA gave overall opinions for all JUs together, in line with how it audits the EU budget.
Lucian Romașcanu, the ECA Member in charge of the audit, said: "The EU joint undertakings channel billions of euros into areas that are crucial for the EU's competitiveness and strategic autonomy". He added: "Their accounts are reliable and their spending is regular overall, but better risk analysis is needed to prevent recurring errors in payments".

Errors in grant payments: mostly staff costs

Grants are about €1.1 billion (52%) of the payments the auditors sampled from, and all errors but one were in grants. The auditors examined 95 transactions and found errors in 14 (15%), against 12 of 63 (19%) the year before. Among the 68 grant payments from Horizon 2020, Horizon Europe and Digital Europe, 13 (19%) had quantifiable errors. All 13 reimbursed actual costs, "mainly incurred for personnel costs by beneficiaries".
The finding that matters most for applicants: the auditors found "no significant differences" in error levels between Horizon 2020 and Horizon Europe, "despite the simplifications" Horizon Europe brought in for personnel cost reporting. In other words, the new rules haven't made staff-cost claims safer in practice.
The worst case was the Global Health EDCTP3 JU. Four of the five Horizon Europe grant payments the auditors sampled were materially affected by beneficiaries' overclaims of personnel costs that the JU didn't detect. The errors were about 8%, 14% and 5% of the amounts audited, and 67% in the fourth case, which included a high level of ineligible bonuses, wrong exchange rates and subsistence allowances paid to people who didn't work for the beneficiary. That earned EDCTP3 a qualified opinion on its payments.
PartnershipWhat went wrong in the sampled grant payments
SESAR 3 (air traffic management)Daily rates calculated from cost estimates instead of actual costs
Clean AviationThe beneficiary used the wrong method to calculate daily rates
IHI (health)Subcontracting costs classified as personnel costs; full annual depreciation of equipment claimed instead of the project's share
Clean HydrogenCosts not recorded in the beneficiary's accounts; Horizon 2020 personnel-cost rules used in Horizon Europe; travel outside the reporting period
ChipsWrong salary basis for hourly rates (a Horizon 2020 grant)
Circular Bio-based EuropeHorizon 2020 personnel-cost rules used, plus ineligible staff-cost elements
EuroHPCEmployer social contributions overstated; annual ceiling of hours per staff member exceeded
Global Health EDCTP3Wrong daily rates and days, wrong exchange rates, ineligible bonuses, allowances for non-staff (4 of 5 payments)
Source: European Court of Auditors, annual report on EU joint undertakings for 2025, chapter 3. The auditors found no errors in the sampled payments of ECCC, Europe's Rail and SNS. They did report shortcomings in four Europe's Rail lump-sum grants: no evidence of a robust check of budgeted personnel costs, and some partners' contributions to deliverables weren't specific enough to assess. Lump sums cut cost reporting, but the budget behind them still gets checked; see how they work in our guide to cost reimbursement vs lump sum grants.

Slow grants: Chips used 42% of its payment budget, SNS 18%

The JUs had a combined payment budget of about €4 billion in 2025 (€3.2 billion in 2024) and paid out about €2.9 billion. On average they used 73% of their payment budgets, from 18% at the Smart Networks and Services (SNS) JU to 99% at the Innovative Health Initiative (IHI) and Global Health EDCTP3. The press release blames "lengthy decision-making processes and complex procedures for spending".
  • Chips JU: €381 million paid out of €901 million (42%). The auditors put it down to the JU's "delay in concluding the grant agreements" from its 2024 and 2025 Horizon Europe calls, and to complex joint procurement for the pilot lines funded under Digital Europe. About €520 million (58%) of unused payment money was moved to later years.
  • SNS JU: €23 million out of €126 million (18%). The Commission was slow to decide on the security provisions under Article 22(5) of the Horizon Europe Regulation, so the 2025 calls couldn't open in time. Grant agreements and pre-financing payments slipped to the first half of 2026.
  • SESAR 3: 37%. The auditors link this to the JU's multiannual Horizon Europe funding cycle rather than to a delay.
For a startup in a consortium, a late grant agreement means a late pre-financing payment. If you're planning around a Chips or SNS call, build a few months' buffer into your cash plan, and see our Horizon Europe guide for SMEs for how the money flows once the grant is signed.

Industry is behind on its share

Joint undertakings are meant to be co-funded: industry and other members add their own cash or in-kind work to the EU money. Across 10 JUs, members had reached on average 45% of their Horizon Europe contribution targets by the end of 2025, five years into the programme. The press release says several JUs "continue to show a significant shortfall in private-sector contributions".
PartnershipField2025 payment budget usedHorizon Europe member contributions vs target (end-2025)
SESAR 3Air traffic management37%53%
Clean AviationLow-emission aircraft71%46%
IHIHealth innovation99%18%
Clean HydrogenHydrogen93%124%
ChipsSemiconductors42%38%
Circular Bio-based EuropeBio-based industries87%26%
Europe's RailRail79%57%
EuroHPCSupercomputing and AI88%25%
SNS5G/6G networks18%61%
Global Health EDCTP3Global health research99%34%
ECCCCybersecurity69%Not applicable
F4EITER fusion project93%Not applicable
Source: European Court of Auditors, annual report on EU joint undertakings for 2025, Figures 2.3 and 2.5. Only Clean Hydrogen is ahead of its target. IHI and Circular Bio-based Europe told the auditors their projects started slowly. At EuroHPC, private members can only count in-kind contributions in innovation grants, which are about 30% of its grants. Under Digital Europe and the Connecting Europe Facility, the Chips JU, EuroHPC and the ECCC were at 50% of their targets on average, and member states had made no voluntary contributions yet to the ECCC's joint actions.
The scale explains why this matters. Under the 2021–2027 budget, the JUs get €11.9 billion from Horizon Europe (about 13% of it) and €5.5 billion from Digital Europe (about 68% of that programme), and other members are expected to add about €19.6 billion. The report notes that these amounts reflect a 2025 Commission decision to move part of the JUs' research funds to AI gigafactories.

What happens next

  • Recommendations (issued): eight JUs (SESAR 3, IHI, Circular Bio-based Europe, Europe's Rail, EuroHPC, SNS, Global Health EDCTP3 and ECCC) must estimate and publish an error rate for their Horizon Europe or Digital Europe spending, by mid-2027. F4E must work more closely with the ITER organisation to stabilise the project design, by end-2027.
  • Discharge (pending): the report feeds the annual discharge procedure. The Council adopts its recommendation by mid-February 2027, and the European Parliament decides by the end of March 2027 whether to grant or postpone discharge for each JU.
  • ITER: the auditors warn that ongoing changes to ITER's technical design could cause more cost overruns and delays for F4E.
Our reading: JUs that now have to estimate and publish error rates are likely to look harder at personnel costs. The same pattern showed up in the ECA's annual report on the EU budget earlier this month, where staff costs were the main source of error in research and SMEs were 30% of the errors, and in its audit of Horizon 2020's industrial leadership money.

Meanwhile: €1.3 million EU grant fraud case in Lithuania

The auditors reported no suspected fraud in the JUs for 2025. Elsewhere, fraud cases are still being found. On 23 October, the European Public Prosecutor's Office (EPPO) in Vilnius charged 12 people over suspected fraud and document forgery in two EU-funded projects, with more than €1.3 million in estimated damage. One was a 2019 training project for 180 employees, where forged participant lists are suspected (nearly €270,000 in damage). The other, running from June 2024 to December 2026, was meant to develop prototypes of a transparent, fully recyclable oxygen-barrier plastic film. It is worth more than €1.5 million, and more than €1.07 million had already been paid. The suspects are also accused of trying to obtain a further €500,000, which wasn't paid. About €15 million in assets were frozen. All suspects are presumed innocent until proven guilty.

What this means for you

  1. Calculate staff costs from actual pay, with the right rules. Every staff-cost error in the table above is avoidable. Use Horizon Europe's daily-rate rules for Horizon Europe grants, base rates on payslips and your accounts, and keep employer contributions and bonuses separate. Our guide to personnel costs and full-time equivalents walks through the maths.
  2. Keep timesheets and records from day one. Hours over the annual ceiling and costs outside the reporting period are easy to spot in an audit. See our guide to time tracking and effort reporting.
  3. Prepare for an audit, even years later. Auditors sample payments at random, and some of the errors they found were in Horizon 2020 projects paid in 2025. Our guide to audit requirements for EU-funded projects lists what to keep.
  4. Plan cash for late grant agreements. Chips and SNS show that time-to-grant can stretch. Don't hire or buy equipment on the assumption that pre-financing arrives on a set date.
  5. Check the partners in JU consortia. Industry members are behind on their contributions in most JUs. When you join a consortium, ask how each partner's share is funded.
Never miss a deadline

All open EU and national calls are in our grant deadlines calendar.

FAQ: the EU auditors' 2025 report on joint undertakings

What are EU joint undertakings?

They are public-private partnerships that run part of the EU's research and digital budget in strategic fields: Chips, Clean Hydrogen, Clean Aviation, Circular Bio-based Europe, Europe's Rail, EuroHPC, IHI, SNS, SESAR 3, Global Health EDCTP3 and the ECCC (cybersecurity), plus Fusion for Energy for ITER. Most publish their own calls on the EU Funding & Tenders portal.

When was the ECA report published?

The European Court of Auditors published its annual report on the EU joint undertakings and assimilated bodies for the 2025 financial year on 23 October 2026.

Did the auditors find fraud?

No. The ECA says it did not detect or report any suspected fraud in the JUs for 2025. It found errors, mainly in personnel costs claimed by grant beneficiaries, and the overall estimated error was below its 2% materiality threshold.

Why did Global Health EDCTP3 get a qualified opinion?

Four of the five Horizon Europe grant payments the auditors examined were materially affected by beneficiaries' overclaims of personnel costs that the JU did not detect, with errors of about 8%, 14%, 5% and 67%.

Why did the Chips JU use only 42% of its payment budget?

According to the ECA, because of delays in concluding grant agreements from its 2024 and 2025 Horizon Europe calls and complex joint procurement for pilot lines under Digital Europe. About €520 million was moved to later years.

Did Horizon Europe's simpler rules reduce staff-cost errors?

Not so far. The auditors found no significant differences in error levels between Horizon 2020 and Horizon Europe, despite the simplifications for personnel cost reporting.
2026-10-26 07:17 Funding news